On this page
- The 30-second verdict
- Luno vs VALR vs Binance: side-by-side table
- Licensing and protection
- Getting rand in and out
- Trading fees on a R10,000 buy
- A year of monthly buying: Luno vs VALR
- Coins, staking and extras
- Apps and everyday use
- P2P and USDT/ZAR liquidity
- Moving coins between them, and keeping records
- Who should pick which
- FAQ
Luno vs VALR is the comparison most South Africans make first, and Binance is usually the third name someone throws into the group chat. The short answer: Luno is the easier start, VALR is the cheaper place to trade, and Binance is the only one of the three without an FSCA licence. Below we show where each one costs you money and where it saves it, with every fee dated so you can see how fresh it is.
All three let you buy bitcoin and USDT with rand. The differences sit in the small print: how rand gets in and out, which button you press to buy, and who you can complain to if a withdrawal goes missing. Those are the parts that decide how much of your R10,000 actually becomes crypto.
The 30-second verdict
If you’re asking “what is better than Luno?”, the honest answer is that VALR is cheaper per trade but not easier, and Binance is bigger but not licensed here. If cost is your reason for leaving Luno, VALR is the like-for-like move; Binance swaps an FSCA licence for a longer coin list.
Luno vs VALR vs Binance: side-by-side table
| Feature | Luno | VALR | Binance |
|---|---|---|---|
| FSCA status | FSP 53314, authorised 11 Apr 2024 | FSP 53308, authorised 12 Apr 2024 | FSP 53694 “processing” since 22 Nov 2023 |
| Base | Observatory, Cape Town; since 2013 | Sandton, Johannesburg; since 2018 | Global |
| Coins / rand pairs | 61 assets / 25 rand pairs | 149 assets / 17 rand pairs | Largest list / USDT/ZAR only |
| EFT deposit | Free | Free, up to 48 hours | Route not verified |
| Normal withdrawal | Free, up to 2 business days | 30 free a month, then R8.50 | Mostly via P2P |
| Fast withdrawal | R20 (RTC banks), R80 others | R30 | Not verified |
| Taker fee, crypto/rand | 0.60% | 0.35% | Not verified |
| Proof of reserves | Monthly attestation by Moore | Hacken audit, Aug 2025 | Not checked here |
FSCA register, official fee pages and public market data, checked 17 Nov 2026.
The table shows the pattern. Luno and VALR are equally cheap to fund; they split on trading fees and withdrawals. Binance’s column is mostly gaps, because its official rand pages are old or contradict each other, and we won’t fill a cell with a number we couldn’t confirm. For the full ranked list with seven more platforms, see our top 10 crypto exchanges.
Neither one lists the coin you want?
Our top-rated platform lists about 300 coins, funded with USDT or BTC you buy in rand locally. It has no FSCA licence and no rand wallet, so read the trade-offs before you sign up.
Read the trade-offs firstOur #1 pick · US FinCEN MSB · NMLS 1804170 · UK FCA reg. FRN 1007192
Licensing and protection
Both local exchanges were among the first crypto firms the FSCA authorised. Luno (Pty) Ltd got FSP 53314 on 11 April 2024 and VALR (Pty) Ltd got FSP 53308 a day later, both for Category I and Category II crypto services. VALR has gone further, with a separate company, VALR DAM, licensed as an over-the-counter derivatives provider (FSP 54897, authorised 20 September 2025). Both are accountable institutions under the FIC Act, which is why they ask for ID, a selfie and proof of address.
What the licence gets you: the FAIS conduct rules apply, and if a complaint isn’t resolved you can take it to the FAIS Ombud. What it doesn’t get you: insurance on your coins, or protection from a falling price.
Both also publish proof of reserves. Luno’s is a monthly attestation by Moore Johannesburg, and you can check that your own balance is included on the web version. VALR’s is a Hacken audit completed in August 2025 that reported more than 100% backing.
Binance is different. The FSCA warned the public about it in 2021, it stopped offering futures, options and margin to South Africans in October 2021, and its local company’s licence application has shown “processing” since 22 November 2023. Using it is not illegal, but if something goes wrong you have no FAIS Ombud and no FSCA route. Our guide to FSCA-licensed crypto exchanges shows how to check any of these numbers in three minutes.
Getting rand in and out
This is where Luno earns its reputation with beginners.
Luno takes EFT deposits for free with no limit. Faster options cost money: instant deposit 1.4% (up to R100,000), Absa Pay 1.4%, Capitec Pay 1.25% under R1,000 or a flat R9 above that, Apple Pay 2.5% (R50 to R30,000), and card buys 3.9%. Normal withdrawals are free and take up to two business days; express withdrawals cost R20 to banks on the real-time clearing system and R80 to other banks.
VALR also takes EFT for free, with no minimum, and clearing can take up to 48 hours. Standard Bank lists VALR as a pre-approved beneficiary. Card deposits through Payfast cost 3.9% with a R20,000 daily limit; a second card route through Checkout.com doesn’t support most South African cards. Individuals get 30 free normal withdrawals a month and pay R8.50 each after that, and a fast withdrawal costs R30 over real-time clearing to 20 banks, including Capitec, FNB, Absa, Nedbank, Standard Bank, TymeBank and Discovery.
Binance is the odd one out. It still runs a USDT/ZAR market, but we couldn’t confirm its current direct rand deposit and withdrawal route from official pages, and most South Africans use its P2P market instead.
The bank-by-bank detail, including Absa Pay and instant EFT providers, is in our guide to ZAR deposits.
Trading fees on a R10,000 buy
Here is what R10,000 of bitcoin or USDT costs to buy on each platform, depending on the button you press. Both local exchanges put you in their entry tier at this size (Luno: up to R20,000 a month; VALR: up to 50,000 USDT over 30 days).
| How you buy | Luno | VALR | Binance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Order book, taker (BTC/ZAR) | R60 (0.60%) | R35 (0.35%) | No BTC/ZAR market |
| Order book, maker (BTC/ZAR) | R40 (0.40%) | R18 (0.18%) | No BTC/ZAR market |
| USDT/ZAR, taker | R20 (0.20%) | R35 (0.35%) | Fee not verified |
| One-tap buy button | R200 (2%) | R160 (1.6%) | — |
| Card | R390 (3.9%) | R390 (3.9%) | — |
| P2P USDT | — | — | About R210 more than VALR’s price |
Entry-tier fees from Luno's and VALR's fee pages, checked 17 Nov 2026. Binance P2P from our 17 Nov 2026 snapshot.
So which is cheaper, Luno or VALR? For bitcoin and other coins against rand, VALR, by R25 on every R10,000 as a taker. For USDT/ZAR, Luno: its 0.20% taker fee beats VALR’s 0.35%, and a filled limit order on Luno’s USDT/ZAR book even earns a tiny rebate (maker fee −0.01%). Both books had a spread of a fraction of a cent on USDT/ZAR on the morning of 17 November 2026, so the fee is the cost that matters there.
The bigger lesson is in the middle row. An order book buy costs R35 to R60; the convenient one-tap button costs R160 to R200 for the same R10,000. That gap is larger than any difference between the two exchanges.
A year of monthly buying: Luno vs VALR
Most people don’t buy once. Here is the same comparison for an illustrative monthly plan: R2,000 into bitcoin at the start of every month for a year, funded by EFT, which is free on both.
| How you buy each month | Luno a month | Luno a year | VALR a month | VALR a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One-tap buy (Luno 2%) or Auto-Buy (VALR 1.6%) | R40 | R480 | R32 | R384 |
| Order book, taker | R12 | R144 | R7 | R84 |
| Limit order that fills, maker | R8 | R96 | R3.60 | R43.20 |
Entry-tier fees from Luno's and VALR's fee pages, checked 17 Nov 2026.
Moving from the convenient button to the order book saves R336 a year on Luno and R300 on VALR, at least five times the R60 a year that separates the two exchanges’ taker fees. A limit order only earns the maker rate if someone trades against it, so on a day when the price runs away from you it may not fill. For a monthly plan that rarely matters: set the limit a little below the current price and check back later.
Saving in USDT instead of bitcoin turns the result around. On USDT/ZAR, Luno’s 0.20% taker fee comes to R4 a month on R2,000, or R48 a year, against R84 a year at VALR’s 0.35%. Someone who parks part of a salary in a dollar stablecoin every month will usually find Luno the cheaper home, while a monthly bitcoin buyer who can pay by EFT is better off on VALR.
The table assumes a free EFT, and that’s where Capitec clients get a different answer. With Capitec’s app blocking ordinary transfers to exchanges, Capitec Pay adds a flat R9 to each R2,000 deposit on Luno, so the taker route costs R21 a month, or R252 a year. Without a Capitec Pay option on VALR, a Capitec-only client is left with VALR’s 3.9% card deposit: R78 a month before any trading fee. For that reader Luno wins comfortably, unless a second account at another bank can pay VALR by EFT.
Coins, staking and extras
Luno lists 61 assets for South African customers, including two rand stablecoins: swapping rand for ZARU is free, while ZARSC is free to buy and costs 3% to sell. It also offers staking, but keeps a service fee of 20% to 40% of the rewards, plus bundles (1% to buy, 1% to sell, 2% a year for rebalancing) and tokenised stocks at 1%.
VALR has 149 spot assets and 17 rand pairs. Its derivatives arm, VALR DAM, holds an ODP licence covering crypto futures, perpetuals, options and CFDs: tools for experienced traders, not a savings plan. Transfers between VALR accounts are free.
Binance has the largest coin list of the three, but futures, options and margin have been off for South African users since October 2021, and every coin other than USDT needs a second trade if you start from rand.
Apps and everyday use
Both local exchanges have phone apps, and both now reach people who never open them.
- Luno Pay lets you pay by QR code in rand or crypto for free, from R1 to R100,000; Luno says it works at nearly a million merchants. Since December 2025 Discovery Bank clients can also link a Luno account inside the Discovery app, with instant free transfers to the Luno wallet.
- VALR Pay works wherever Zapper, Scan to Pay, Ozow or Peach Payments are accepted, with examples from Pick n Pay and Clicks to Engen and FlySafair. FNB’s in-app crypto trading, launched on 6 October 2026, also runs on VALR, though coins bought there can’t be moved out.
- Binance Pay is one of the wallets MoneyBadger accepts at Pick n Pay tills and other merchants, alongside Luno and VALR.
One practical difference: Luno’s proof-of-reserves check runs on the web version only, so you’ll need a browser for that. Our ranking of the best crypto apps compares the phone experience across more platforms, including the banking apps.
P2P and USDT/ZAR liquidity
USDT/ZAR is the busiest rand market in South Africa, and the gap between the three is large. In the 24 hours to 08:10 UTC on 17 November 2026, VALR’s USDT/ZAR book traded about R259.5 million, Luno’s about R16.7 million and Binance’s about R13.4 million. On Luno and VALR you buy from the order book, so you deal with the exchange’s market, not a stranger’s bank account.
Binance’s strength is P2P: you pay another person by bank transfer while Binance holds their USDT in escrow. Our snapshot that morning found 44 adverts selling USDT and 106 buying, with payment methods from Capitec and FNB transfers to cash deposits and MTN Mobile Money. The cheapest seller asked R17.40 per USDT, about 2.1% more than VALR’s price of R17.0375.
P2P is also where most South African crypto fraud lands. In Wessels v Petrus, scammers posing as Capitec’s fraud department took R960,960 from a pensioner and paid it into a Binance P2P seller’s Capitec account; the court held that the seller could not hand his FICA checks over to Binance. Read our P2P crypto guide before you trade with strangers.
Moving coins between them, and keeping records
Moving coins from Luno to VALR, or back, is a transfer between two South African licensed exchanges. You pay the sending exchange’s network fee and fill in the travel-rule details, but under the Reserve Bank’s draft Crypto Asset Manual a transfer between South African custodial wallets at providers authorised under the new rules would count as domestic. Sending the same coins to Binance is different: under that draft, crypto sent to a foreign exchange would count against your SDA. The draft is not law and may change, but it’s worth knowing which kind of transfer you’re making. Our guide to exchange control and crypto tracks where the rules stand.
Using two exchanges also means your tax records have to work across both. For crypto held as an investment, SARS allows only specific identification or first-in-first-out, not a weighted average, so if you buy bitcoin on Luno, move it to VALR and sell it there, your cost price comes from the original Luno purchase. Download both statements after every tax year ends on 28 February and keep them for at least five years, the period SARS’s draft crypto guide gives. Our crypto tax guide shows how to put them together.
Who should pick which
Luno suits a beginner who wants to buy now and then, a Capitec client who needs Capitec Pay, or someone who withdraws to the bank more than 30 times a month. Learn the exchange screen early so you don’t pay 2% on every buy. Our Luno review goes deeper on its fees and limits.
VALR suits anyone who buys every month or trades actively: the 0.35% taker fee and the depth of its rand books make it the cheaper long-term home. Our VALR review goes deeper on its fees and licences.
Binance suits experienced users who need a global market VALR and Luno don’t list, and who accept the missing FSCA licence. Is Binance better than Luno? On coin choice, yes; on protection and rand rails, no, and the same goes for VALR vs Binance. Our Binance South Africa guide explains what “processing” means for you.
Moving coins between them is allowed, but it now comes with paperwork. Under the crypto travel rule, Luno and VALR must collect the recipient’s details for every transfer out and must reject it if they’re missing. Whichever way you lean in Luno vs VALR, send a small test transfer first and keep the records for SARS.
Want more coins than either local exchange lists?
Buy USDT or BTC in rand here, send it to our top-rated exchange and reach about 300 assets plus savings and staking. Try a small test transfer first.
See the full top 10Our #1 pick · US FinCEN MSB · NMLS 1804170 · UK FCA reg. FRN 1007192
Frequently asked questions
Is Luno or VALR cheaper?
Is Binance licensed in South Africa?
Which is better for beginners, Luno or VALR?
Can I move crypto from Luno to Binance?
Which has more coins?
Sources we checked
- ↗FSCA — Check if a firm is authorised (FSP search)
- ↗Luno — South African fees and limits
- ↗Luno — Licences
- ↗Luno — Proof of reserves
- ↗VALR — Fees
- ↗VALR — Licences and registrations
- ↗VALR — VALR Pay
- ↗VALR — Public market summary API
- ↗Luno — Public tickers API
- ↗Binance — Exchange information API (ZAR pairs)
- ↗Discovery Bank — Crypto with Luno in the banking app
- ↗SARB — Draft Crypto Asset Manual for cross-border activities (draft, 2026)
- ↗SARS — Clarification on base cost for crypto assets (IT3(c), 2 Jun 2026)
- ↗SARS — Draft Guide to the Taxation of Crypto Assets (1 Jul 2026)
Risk note: crypto prices can fall sharply and you can lose all the money you put in. This page is general information, not financial or tax advice. Fees, limits and licences change; check them on the provider’s site and the FSCA register before you act.





